What the vote does — and what it doesn’t
Pasadena’s Flock cameras are on their way out — just not tonight. The City Council voted 7-0 on Tuesday night to let the city’s contract with Flock Safety lapse when its paid term runs out in February 2027, declining the final one-year option and turning down Police Chief Eugene Harris’s recommendation to extend the program through February 2028.
Councilmember Tyron Hampton abstained. He wanted the contract ended immediately, not left to run out.
It was the first time the full council had taken up the program since approving it in July 2023. Vice Mayor Jess Rivas made the motion; Councilmember Steve Madison seconded it.
The cameras stay up — for now
The decision ends the city’s relationship with Flock Safety, but the cameras don’t go dark. The department’s 61 fixed cameras will keep operating through the service period the city has already paid for, which runs into February 2027, and the city will pay nothing more. The extension the chief sought — up to $152,500 from existing appropriations to keep the cameras running through February 2028 — is off the table.
What the vote does not do is set a date to take the cameras down, or verify that the data they collected gets deleted — no deletion order was adopted. Those were central to the open letters sent to the council ahead of the vote, including mine.
The motion bars the city from issuing a request for proposals for a replacement vendor now — the “no replacement” position Rivas staked out in August. But Madison’s amendment says it does not prohibit future discussion of ALPR-type technology, with a high bar for any future vendor. City staff will study license-plate readers and any replacement technology, with public input through the Community Police Oversight Commission, the Public Safety Committee and the council itself.
A long night, and a changed council
Sixty-three speaker cards. More than four hours. And exactly one public speaker in support of keeping the cameras: Robert Griffith of the Pasadena Police Officers Association. The letters told the same story: 538 opposed continuing the program, and two supported it.
Several councilmembers said they had changed their minds — Rivas and Mayor Gordo among them — citing concerns about data-sharing, accuracy, federal access to the data, and warrantless tracking. Councilmember Justin Jones put it bluntly: “if I found out that I had cancer today, I would cut it out today.” The department’s case rested on results: Flock alerts had helped recover 27 of 89 stolen vehicles. It wasn’t enough.
How long the city keeps the data — 30 days now, with 7 days proposed — is unchanged for now, and will presumably be part of the study. But the study has no deadline yet, and neither does removal.
Pasadena joins a wave
On Monday, San Diego’s council voted unanimously to end its Flock contract, covering 500 cameras, after learning the department had used the system to track a domestic-violence victim and one of its own officers. Culver City voted 3-2 the same night to terminate its contract immediately.
Pasadena’s decision is narrower than any of those: a lapse, not a termination; February 2027, not tonight. What happens after that — removal, or a replacement system — is still undecided.
What to watch
Four things, in order:
- A removal date. Set one now — not 61 cameras on poles indefinitely after February 2027.
- The outside-agency cutoff. Councilmember Rick Cole’s amendment asks the City Attorney whether the city can cut off access by the roughly 300 other agencies while the cameras run to February. Watch for that answer.
- Proof the data is deleted — and an accounting of who has had access to it.
- The study and the policy. The staff study should be public, and so should the comprehensive policy on the city’s technologies, data ownership, cloud storage, AI and cybersecurity that Mayor Gordo asked staff to bring back.
Meanwhile, the city manager search goes on: the council met in closed session Monday, and no appointment has been announced. With the November 24 meeting expected to be cancelled, the next session is December 1.
Sources: Pasadena Now (Nov. 18 and Nov. 16, 2026); City of Pasadena council meeting video, Nov. 17, 2026 (Pasadena Media); NBC 7 San Diego and Culver City Crossroads (Nov. 16, 2026); Vice Mayor Jess Rivas, District 5 newsletter (Aug. 25, 2026).